Gilbertsville, NY

View of Gilbertsville, NY
Population
326
U.S. Census Population Estimates Program · 2025
Elevation
1,097 ft
USGS GNIS community points and 3DEP elevation · GNIS 2026-07-06; USGS 3DEP sampled 2026-07-23
Median Home Value
$165,000
U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-Year · 2024
Median Rent
$1,141/mo
U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-Year · 2024
Median Income
$81,500
U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-Year · 2024
General Quality
Overall rating out of 100

Highlights

What stands out in Gilbertsville

Explore

More places like Gilbertsville

About Gilbertsville

Tucked along Butternut Creek west of Oneonta, Gilbertsville is a quiet Otsego County village of around 300 people. The area offers scenic rural surroundings and a remarkably preserved historic center. Distinctive landmarks like the Major's Inn, an elaborate Tudor-style estate built around the turn of the 20th century, give the village an architectural character rarely found in communities of this size.

Gilbertsville owes much of its timeless feel to the dedication of its residents. During the 1970s, locals organized a successful grassroots campaign to stop a federal dam project that would have flooded the valley and submerged the village. That preservation effort led to the entire village being listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Today, that enduring pride creates a close-knit, welcoming community for anyone looking for peaceful Upstate New York living.

Top Rating Signals

Highest current ratings for this town.

Loading town details...

Beyond Gilbertsville, NY

Is this the right place for you?

Every rating on this page comes from the same model behind our search. Tell us what matters to you and we’ll rank every community we cover around your priorities, and show you where Gilbertsville, NY lands.

Find your best places
Google MapsOpen the mapGilbertsville, NYZillowBrowse housingGilbertsville, NYWeatherSparkCheck climateGilbertsville, NYRedditSearch discussionsGilbertsville, NY