Middletown, IN

True to its name, Middletown sits right between Anderson and New Castle, making it a practical choice for anyone looking for a quiet home base in east-central Indiana. A historic downtown filled with classic brick storefronts gives the town a cozy, established feel, while shaded residential streets and green spaces along Fall Creek offer plenty of room to unwind. Everyday living here is peaceful and budget-friendly, with good local schools, an active community library, and straightforward drives whenever you need major retail or job centers nearby.