Otter Lake, NY

Population
77
U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-Year · 2024
Elevation
1,537 ft
USGS GNIS community points and 3DEP elevation · GNIS 2026-07-06; USGS 3DEP sampled 2026-07-23
Median Home Value
$251,800
U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-Year · 2024
General Quality
Overall rating out of 100

Highlights

What stands out in Otter Lake

Explore

More places like Otter Lake

About Otter Lake

Tucked along Route 28 in the western Adirondacks, Otter Lake is a quiet community where everyday life centers on the water. Once an old logging hub, the area has settled into a relaxed neighborhood of classic shoreline cottages, private docks, and cozy year-round homes. An active local association maintains the shared boat launch and hosts neighborhood get-togethers throughout the summer. It offers a scenic, easygoing spot to settle down, combining peaceful waterfront living with quick access to nearby Old Forge and surrounding mountain trails.

Top Rating Signals

Highest current ratings for this town.

Loading town details...

Beyond Otter Lake, NY

Is this the right place for you?

Every rating on this page comes from the same model behind our search. Tell us what matters to you and we’ll rank every community we cover around your priorities, and show you where Otter Lake, NY lands.

Find your best places
Google MapsOpen the mapOtter Lake, NYZillowBrowse housingOtter Lake, NYWeatherSparkCheck climateOtter Lake, NYRedditSearch discussionsOtter Lake, NY