Spencer, NY

View of Spencer, NY
Population
688
U.S. Census Population Estimates Program · 2025
Elevation
994 ft
USGS GNIS community points and 3DEP elevation · GNIS 2026-07-06; USGS 3DEP sampled 2026-07-23
Median Home Value
$154,300
U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-Year · 2024
Median Rent
$1,046/mo
U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-Year · 2024
Median Income
$51,765
U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-Year · 2024
General Quality
Overall rating out of 100

Highlights

What stands out in Spencer

Explore

More places like Spencer

About Spencer

Tucked into a quiet valley just south of Ithaca, Spencer offers a peaceful, rural setting with an easy commute to both the Finger Lakes and the Southern Tier. Catatonk Creek winds right through the heart of the village, where state routes 34 and 96 meet before branching off toward the surrounding hills. Settled in the late 1700s and historically nicknamed Pumpkin Hook, the community combines deep upstate roots with a relaxed, down-to-earth pace of life.

For anyone considering a move, daily living here centers on a close-knit small-town feel and plenty of open space. Families are served by the shared Spencer-Van Etten School District, and local gatherings bring neighbors together throughout the year. With scenic country roads, easy access to nearby outdoor recreation, and a quick drive into Ithaca for dining, shopping, and jobs, Spencer provides a quiet home base with regional conveniences close at hand.

Top Rating Signals

Highest current ratings for this town.

Loading town details...

Beyond Spencer, NY

Is this the right place for you?

Every rating on this page comes from the same model behind our search. Tell us what matters to you and we’ll rank every community we cover around your priorities, and show you where Spencer, NY lands.

Find your best places
Google MapsOpen the mapSpencer, NYZillowBrowse housingSpencer, NYWeatherSparkCheck climateSpencer, NYRedditSearch discussionsSpencer, NY