Amagansett, NY

Tucked between East Hampton and Montauk on Long Island's South Fork, Amagansett offers a quiet, laid-back coastal retreat with a strong sense of community. Originally settled in 1680, the village takes its name from the Montaukett phrase for "place of good water," which fits its easy access to Atlantic Avenue Beach and Indian Wells Beach. Preserved historic homes, open farmland, and tree-lined lanes give the area a timeless feel, blending classic East End heritage with a relaxed, down-to-earth beach lifestyle.

ATTRThomas Moran / Public domain

Everyday life revolves around a compact Main Street filled with local coffee shops, independent boutiques, farm stands, and iconic spots like the Stephen Talkhouse. Families benefit from the small, attentive Amagansett School for younger children, while older students head into East Hampton for middle and high school. Getting around is straightforward along Montauk Highway, and the local Long Island Rail Road station provides a direct link west toward the city. For new residents, it offers an appealing balance of natural ocean beauty and village warmth.