Island Heights, NJ

Island Heights is a quiet borough perched on the bluffs overlooking the Toms River. Home to around 1,600 residents, it offers a peaceful, historic small-town feel right where the river opens into Barnegat Bay. The town originated in the late 1800s as a Victorian camp-meeting retreat, and that distinct character remains in its shady, sloping streets, historic cottages, and status as a dry town. While it feels tucked away from heavy coastal traffic, all the shopping, dining, and healthcare services of Toms River are just minutes away.

ATTRFamartin / CC BY-SA 4.0

Families with young children have a local elementary school right in town, while middle and high school students attend the nearby Central Regional district. Daily routines often revolve around the water, from morning walks along the riverfront boardwalk to sailing out of the local yacht club. While lower waterfront roads require some attention during coastal storms, much of the borough sits comfortably high on the bluffs. It is an appealing option for buyers seeking historic charm, maritime recreation, and a close-knit neighborhood on the Jersey Shore.