Muttontown, NY

View of Muttontown, NY
Image credit: AITFFan1 / CC BY-SA 4.0
Population
3,568
U.S. Census Population Estimates Program · 2025
Elevation
292 ft
Median Home Value
$1,914,800
U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-Year · 2024
Median Income
$250,001
U.S. Census American Community Survey 5-Year · 2024

Explore

Muttontown in context.

About Muttontown

Muttontown is a small, affluent village on Long Island's North Shore, within the greater Syosset and Oyster Bay area. The land was historically inhabited by Matinecock people before European settlement, and the village later became known for estates, large lots, and wooded residential roads. It is served by several school districts, including Jericho, Locust Valley, and Oyster Bay-East Norwich. Muttontown feels residential, private, and spacious, with more of an estate-village character than a conventional Long Island suburb.

Top Rating Signals

Highest current ratings for this town.

Loading town details...