Schaefer Lake, IN

Schaefer Lake is a quiet, close-knit neighborhood centered around a private reservoir in northeastern Bartholomew County. If you are looking for waterfront living with a relaxed pace, this small pocket of homes offers calm water, fishing, and boating right outside your door. It sits about thirteen miles northeast of Columbus, giving residents an easy drive to regional shopping, dining, and major employers.

The community took shape in the 1950s when Albert Schaefer dammed Duck Creek to build a dedicated retreat. Over the decades, it grew from a collection of weekend cabins into a year-round neighborhood managed by an active property owners association. Today, residents enjoy scenic lakeside living with a laid-back feel, all while staying just minutes away from the historic town of Hope.